Being a Chicago White Sox fan, I’ve been interested in the recent “controversy” surrounding the team - which surprisingly isn’t about Ozzie Guillen’s recent tirade that would have made Lee Elia proud.
No, this controversy is about something else entirely.
While mired in a six game losing streak where the team’s offense has essentially disappeared, someone on the team thought that they would do something a little fun to try and lighten the mood and turn their luck around.
Before Sunday’s game in Toronto, one of the players positioned two nude blowup dolls in the clubhouse with bats of the players fanning out around them - a ritual of sorts to try and get the team out of its slump.
Apparently the media was permitted into the clubhouse while this shrine was still out in the open and the incident has been blowing up ever since.
Why is everyone so up in arms over this incident?
Is it degrading to women?
That depends on the woman that you ask, I am sure. After asking my wife about it, she said that she didn’t believe that something like this is degrading to women.
Is it inappropriate for the workplace?
That depends on your workplace.
While I am sure that placing a blowup doll in my office would not go over well, neither would spitting on the floor and walking around scratching my family jewels every five minutes.
But I don’t believe that the clubhouse of a professional sports team is quite the same as a corporate office. It is not uncommon for an athlete to spend more time in the clubhouse than they do in their own home; and I am sure there are more than a few people that have things like this in their home.
Do you remember the movie Major League?
Bats, they are sick. I cannot hit curveball. Straightball I hit it very much. Curveball, bats are afraid. I ask Jobu to come, take fear from bats. I offer him cigar, rum. He will come.
- Pedro Cerrano
Many athletes are extremely superstitious and will do just about anything to try and guarantee their success. There are players that won’t shave until they lose, or won’t change their game socks, or wear the same t-shirt every game.
In my opinion, this incident with the Chicago White Sox and the blowup dolls is nothing more than a group of grown men doing something a little juvenile in an attempt to turn around their misfortune.
Nothing more, nothing less.
Anyone that says otherwise is just blowing hot air.
What do you think?


















The Man Page is your home to get career advice, parenting tips, or just kick back and escape from the pressure of being a man. Join Derek Semmler - a working husband and father to two young boys, as we tackle the issues facing men today and have a good deal of fun in the process. He also blogs at 

It’s not just atheletes. I’ve always think that all sports fans have some kind of superstition. If you don’t have any at all, you are probably not into it enough.
I think the club house is more of a home than a work place. Of course, if you are a celebrity, you probably don’t want blow dolls lying around when you invite the media over. However, even if you do, it will become a story that people talk about. It’s never a crime though.
Kelvin Kaos last blog post..The Most Amazing Worms in the World!
Lol, as a fan I have my own sick superstitions. You might not believe it but the reason the Chicago Bears lost a few games this year was because I was watching on the wrong TV.
as a woman, i personally dont find this offensive. It is more silly-stupid to me.
let this be a lesson boys! clean up after yourself! :p
The media always looks at everything in a bad light. They carry on about this doll thing like someone got murdered. It was just a harmless way to put some spirit back into a bad situation. Kind of a twisted way, but hey everyone has their own way of dealing with things.
Just a little harmless activity, they should quit making it more than it is.
Sara Fergusons last blog post..Writing Daily - Tips for Blogging - Finding Your Voice.
I agree, some may consider this poor taste, however, the news they were probably having a slow news day and needed someone to pick on to have something to say.
Things like this are usually meant in fun, so thats how I’m looking at it..even as a grandmother..
Dorothy from grammology
remember to call gram
grammology.com